Doctor Rank
Back to Marketing Guide
AI Search

Where Dermatologists Must Be Listed for AI Search in 2027

Written by Artem Saribekyan, Founder and CEO of Doctor Rank. Twenty years in search marketing for medical practices. Building AI search and AI receptionist systems for practices since ChatGPT launched in late 2022. Last updated November 2026.

We asked ChatGPT and Google AI which registries and directories decide "best dermatologist in my city". Their lists are the floor. What they missed is what moves the answer: the rating gate, orphaned directory profiles and the med spa next door.

ChatGPT and Google AI named the credential registries a dermatology practice needs. From auditing real clinics: the 4.8 rating gate on "best" searches, directory profiles created by old agencies, med spas with a board-certified dermatologist, and what is worth paying for.

Artem Saribekyan

Artem Saribekyan

CEO, Doctor Rank

November 15, 20269 min read
Where Dermatologists Must Be Listed for AI Search in 2027

The short answer

We asked ChatGPT and Google AI where a dermatology practice has to be listed to be named for "best dermatologist in my city" in 2026 and 2027. Both answered with the credential registries: the American Board of Dermatology, the NPI registry, the state medical board, the AAD, Medicare's Care Compare. Those are right and they are table stakes. What both left out is what decides the answer in the clinics I audit: your Google rating when the word "best" is in the question, directory profiles created years ago by someone else, and how a med spa with a board-certified dermatologist slides in behind you.

Below: the exact question we asked, both answers in full, the four things they missed, and what is worth paying for.

You still rank on Google and the phone rings less

This is written for the established practice, often with more than one location, that held the top of local search for years. The rankings are mostly still there. The new patient calls are not what they were a year ago, and some of you have started to see positions move. I see this pattern in audit after audit, and the cause is not the website alone.

The last time search changed this much was Google's Panda update in 2011. In plain terms, Panda pushed down sites built from thin, repeated pages and rewarded sites that answered a real question in depth. Google described it as finding more high-quality sites, and later published the questions it wanted site owners to ask themselves. AI search is the same kind of shift, with one difference: ChatGPT, Google AI Overviews and Perplexity do not stop at your website. Before they name a practice they read your Google profile, your reviews, the medical registries and the directories, and they check that all of it tells one story. It keeps getting better at this, which is why a practice that only maintained its site is slipping.

The question we asked ChatGPT and Google AI

We gave both systems the same prompt, word for word:

Act as an AI search retrieval and entity verification system. When a patient asks for the "best dermatologist in [City]" in 2026 and 2027, which specific third-party directories, credential boards, and data sources are mandatory for a clinic to be cited in your response?

Their answers are below as they gave them, trimmed only for length. My read on them follows.

What ChatGPT said

ChatGPT kept its answer to primary-source medical verification. Its list:

"For 2026 and 2027, ABD/ABMS certification verification and state medical licensing records should carry substantially more weight than commercial directories, review scores, or med spa marketing. The other platforms help establish discoverability and corroborate identity; they cannot substitute for medical credentials."

ChatGPT's closing line, quoted.

What Google AI said

Google AI went wider and ranked ten data sources by how much trust it assigns each one. This table is its answer, reformatted and nothing else.

RankSourceTierWhat it reads there
1American Board of Dermatology / ABMSTier 1, credentialingActive board certification and subspecialty, for example Mohs surgery
2CMS NPPES (NPI registry)Tier 1, identity coreThe 10-digit NPI and the dermatology taxonomy code
3American Academy of DermatologyTier 1, associationActive Fellow status (FAAD) and the practice profile
4State medical board licensing databasesTier 1, regulatoryActive license, disciplinary history, legal entity ownership
5Hospital system and academic rostersTier 2, institutionalAdmitting privileges, faculty appointments, affiliations
6CMS Care CompareTier 2, federal qualityMedicare enrollment, graduation year, group practice links
7DoximityTier 2, peer graphPhysician network, residency training, publications
8Castle Connolly and regional Top Doctors listsTier 3, editorial vettingPeer-nominated reputation with third-party screening
9Healthgrades, WebMD, VitalsTier 3, aggregator graphName, address and phone consistency; condition and procedure mapping
10Zocdoc and insurance payer directoriesTier 3, commercial utilityInsurance participation and verified appointment data

Both answers are correct as far as they go. A model checks your NPI, your board certification and your license first so it never recommends someone it cannot verify. If that were the whole story, every certified dermatologist with a clean license would be named, and they are not.

What both missed, from auditing real clinics

The word "best" turns your Google rating into a gate

Neither answer put Google Business Profile reviews near the top. In my clients' data they decide more than anything on those lists once a patient adds one word. For "dermatologist near me" or "dermatologist in [city]" a 4.5 or 4.6 still gets considered. For "best dermatologist in [city]" a profile under 4.8 is set aside in nearly every case I have checked across our dermatology and aesthetic practices. Set aside means the model does not go on to look at your credentials or your directories at all. It also reads what the reviews say, the words as well as the stars.

The one exception I see: your competitors' websites are vague. If their pages do not answer what a patient actually wants to know, which insurances you take, how long the first visit lasts, whether they will be rushed, who exactly the dermatologist is and what their training was, and yours do, you can be considered with a lower rating. That is the case for making your dermatology website specific instead of vague, and for treating reviews as part of your search work every month.

Listings created years ago, often by someone else

Almost every established clinic I audit has old directory records: a previous address, a disconnected phone number, a profile created when the doctor worked somewhere else. Some owners do not know the profiles exist. The large healthcare marketing agencies have partnerships with Zocdoc, WebMD and Vitals and can create profiles in bulk for a client. Nobody stays with one agency forever, and when the practice leaves, the logins stay behind. When those practices come to us and we ask how to get into these platforms, the usual answer is that the previous agency created them and they have no idea.

It gets worse than stale data. In a surprising number of cases the doctor is still shown at a rival practice, sometimes in another city, from a job years ago. A model that sees your website say one thing and WebMD or the NPI record say another loses confidence in both. The fix is not glamorous: reset access and sign in as the practice, with the doctor's permission; when a platform asks for identity proof, something like the last four digits of the DEA number is what it wants, and it is used only for that reset. Busy doctors do not have the hours for this, which is why it stays undone. The rule to hold is simple: the directories, the website and the Google Business Profile must tell one story about who works where.

Med spas with a board-certified dermatologist land right behind you

When someone asks for a dermatologist and does not mention Botox or fillers, the model assumes a medical question and puts the dermatology practices first. The med spas that employ a board-certified dermatologist come right after them. If you run a hybrid practice, or a med spa that wants to appear in that answer at all, these five are not negotiable:

  1. A board-certified physician attached to the practice. Without one you do not win this search. A Castle Connolly Top Doctor on staff is better still.
  2. That physician's name on the website, not only in the Google profile.
  3. Every injector, nurse practitioner and physician assistant listed on the site with the treatments they perform and the physician who supervises them.
  4. If you are a dermatology clinic that also does cosmetics, the primary Google category stays Dermatologist. If you are strictly a med spa, stay a med spa. Do not dilute either one.
  5. Medical and cosmetic services kept apart on the site, so a reader and a model can see the clinical depth next to the aesthetic menu.

What is worth paying for, and what is not

Owners ask me which of the commercial platforms on Google's list deserve money. None of them, as listings. Claim them, make the name, address, phone and roster match your website exactly, and move on. Paying for an upgraded Healthgrades, WebMD or Vitals profile does not change how a model reads you; a correct free one does.

Zocdoc is the exception, and only if you want appointments rather than visibility. Some of our clients keep paying for it because it sends patients. They report roughly $100 to $150 per booking request. When you are opening a location or bringing on an associate who needs a schedule, that can be worth it.

Castle Connolly is the opposite case. You cannot buy your way on: peers nominate you and Castle Connolly reviews the nomination; a fee comes only after a physician is selected. That barrier is why a Top Doctor on your staff carries weight in an AI answer. If one of your dermatologists has it, it belongs on the site and in the structured data as much as on the office wall.

Who this is written for

The multi-location dermatology practice that ranked well through the middle of 2026, still ranks in most places, and sees fewer calls and the first ranking changes. Search is changing under you the way it did in 2011, and the practices that only kept their website current are the ones slipping. The registries both AIs listed are the floor. The rating gate, the orphaned directory profiles and the med spa next door are what move the answer.

Related: how to claim your practice's ChatGPT profile, how Google AI Overviews pick a practice, and the dermatology blocks on our client results page.

Questions dermatology practice owners ask about AI search listings

Does my Google rating matter if my practice already ranks?

For a plain search like "dermatologist near me" a 4.5 or 4.6 can still surface. The moment the word "best" is in the question, my clients' data says a profile under 4.8 is set aside in nearly every case, and the model never gets as far as checking credentials. The exception is a market where every competitor's website is vague.

How do I get into directory profiles another agency created for my doctors?

Ask the old agency first. When they will not or cannot hand over logins, the platforms let the practice reset access and sign in as the owner. They may ask for identity proof, which can include the last four digits of the physician's DEA number; that is done with the doctor's permission and used only for the reset. Then correct the address, phone, roster and the practice the doctor is linked to.

Should a dermatology clinic that offers Botox list itself as a med spa?

No. Keep Dermatologist as the primary category and list the cosmetic services underneath. A dermatology query is read as a medical question first; a clinic filed as a med spa drops behind the dermatology practices for it.

Is Zocdoc worth paying for?

Only if you want booked appointments now. Clients of ours who use it report roughly $100 to $150 per booking request. That can make sense for a new location or a new associate who needs a full schedule. It does nothing for how AI search sees you that a correct free listing does not.

Can I pay to be listed as a Castle Connolly Top Doctor?

No. Peers nominate you and Castle Connolly reviews the nomination. A fee comes into play only after a physician is selected. That is exactly why the listing carries weight in an AI answer: it cannot be bought.

Losing calls while you still rank?

On a free call I look at how Google and ChatGPT see your locations today, where the directory records disagree with your site, and what to fix first. Doctor Rank works with one dermatology practice per city, with the founder on every account. The service itself is on the SEO for dermatologists page.

Book a free call with Artem
Artem Saribekyan

Written by

Artem Saribekyan

Artem is the CEO and founder of Doctor Rank, a digital marketing agency specializing in local SEO and AI search optimization for private medical practices. Based in New York, Doctor Rank manages SEO and marketing for over 20 medical practices including plastic surgeons, dermatologists, med spas, cosmetic dentists and psychiatrists.

Learn more about our team

Ready to Get Found in AI Search?

Book a free strategy call and we'll show you exactly how to get ChatGPT, Perplexity, and Google AI to recommend your practice.

Request Private Consultation